As people age, changes in mood, memory, or behavior can raise concerns. Families often wonder whether these changes are signs of a mental illness, such as depression or anxiety or the onset of a neurocognitive condition like Alzheimer’s disease. While there can be overlap in symptoms, understanding the differences is key to ensuring proper diagnosis and treatment.

Mental illness in older adults

Mental illness refers to conditions that affect mood, thinking, and behaviour. In seniors, the most common are depression, anxiety, and late-onset psychosis. Symptoms may include:

• Persistent sadness or withdrawal from activities
• Excessive worry or nervousness
• Changes in appetite or sleep patterns
• Difficulty concentrating
• Feelings of hopelessness or guilt

Importantly, mental illness is not a normal part of aging and is often treatable through therapy, medication, or lifestyle interventions.

Alzheimer’s Disease

Alzheimer’s disease is a progressive neurological disorder that affects memory, reasoning, and daily functioning. Unlike mental illness, it is caused by physical changes in the brain. Symptoms include:

• Short-term memory loss that disrupts daily life
• Difficulty completing familiar tasks
• Confusion with time or place
• Language difficulties (forgetting words, repeating sentences)
• Personality and behavioural changes
• Gradual decline in independence

Unlike depression or anxiety, Alzheimer’s worsens over time and cannot be reversed, though treatment can help slow progression and improve quality of life.

Key differences

• Onset: Mental illness can appear suddenly at any stage of life; Alzheimer’s develops gradually, often over years.
• Course: Mental illness may improve with treatment; Alzheimer’s is progressive and degenerative.
• Memory: In Alzheimer’s, memory loss is a central and worsening symptom ; in depression, memory may feel impaired but typically improves with mood.
• Awareness: People with depression or anxiety are usually aware of their difficulties ; those with Alzheimer’s may lack insight into their memory or behavioural changes.

Why accurate diagnosis matters

Because symptoms can overlap, it is essential for older adults to receive a thorough medical evaluation. Early diagnosis ensures the right treatment whether that means therapy and medication for a mental illness, or specialised care and planning for Alzheimer’s disease. Bottom line: Mental illness and Alzheimer’s disease are different conditions, but both require attention, compassion, and professional care. Recognising the distinctions can help families make informed decisions and provide the right support.

Back to News